Lebanon-Palestine: Israel will have to refund all destroyed infrastructures Print E-mail
Written by Franck Biancheri   
Wednesday, 02 August 2006
Image My paper on the Middle-East "The EU must take risks in the Middle-East" was written and published in French (L'UE doit prendre des risques au Proche-Orient - 14/07) three days before Israel launched their attack on Lebanon; it therefore mainly focused on defining a future pro-active European policy regarding the Israelo-Palestinian conflict. In this paper I underlined the necessity for the EU to set up rules designed to « civilise » confrontations between the two parties, in particular during those crises that regularly affect the region.
        
Concerning Israel I mentioned the idea that it was high time for the Europeans to sanction (by means of economic and commercial sanctions) the systematic destruction of public and private infrastructures in Palestine, destructions which have become all along the years a speciality of the Israeli army. It is this approach (combined with its equivalent towards the Palestinian side) that I will advise Newropeans to adopt in their upcoming debates in defining their EU external policy propositions.

I could not imagine that this infrastructure issue was about to become a burning theme of the international news a few days later, with large scale destructions by Israel of Lebanese roads, bridges, ports, plants, airports… under the pretext of terrorist hunt. I say « under the pretext » as in fact those who suffer from these strikes are not the terrorists (merely called « fighters » by others) but the civilians suddenly unable to move, work, heal…  Such rhetoric and brutal military practice remind us how the US, in less than three years, as a result of its invasion of Iraq, lost all the moral credit accumulated by generations of Americans. In the same way, Israel is committing a moral suicide through this unforgivable action. I wrote this to my Israeli friends (mostly, young association leaders whom I met during my December 2005 round of conferences in Israel), highlighting the fact that their current leaders were heavily compromising their future, as much US leaders have with their population’s.

With such unforgivable operations, these leaders are entailing their populations in more and more dangerous political and moral – see economical - deadlocks. Behind the present decisions made by Tel-Aviv, the same circles which supported the invasion of Iraq in Washington (neo-cons, evangelists and ultra-Zionists) are at work. Israelis are about to undergo the same disappointments and snubs as the US citizens who, them too, were 80% to support the same show-demiurges only four years ago!

The same bitter scenario is shaping up already! Hatred of Israel in the Arab and Muslim world is being multiplied tenfold as a result of its double military offensive on Gaza and Lebanon. And incomprehension (one always close to rejection) grows among the European public opinion, regardless of the country. European leaders are disconnected more than ever from the populations, and their collective passivity [1], partly provoked by Washington, conceals a sad reality: for the Europeans, the Hebrew state is becoming the central component of a problem, instead of being part of the solution. Nothing is yet final, but the trend is accelerating and the actions now conducted by Israel are making it more sustainable.

Something is sure already: Israel must be brought back in line with international law. There is no excuse in the world or in History than can justify Israel’s positioning above international law. For the Europeans of the years to come, who intend to turn the EU into a global force striving for the state of law (rather than the use of strength) to found global governance, it will not be acceptable that any state pretends to outlaw itself. Like the Bush administration is painfully rediscovering it, the « rest of the world » weighs too much for anyone, even the strongest state, to pretend free oneself from the constraints it conveys. Consequently and by anticipation, no one should “dream” that the memory of the « Holocaust » will justify in the Europeans eyes that Israel gets the right to any exorbitant status within the international legal framework. Quite the contrary, such actions are committed when certain leaders and political forces, full of contempt for the others and for international laws, are let loose. If the Shoah and its consequences have given a lesson likely to strengthen the legal framework of the Middle-East conflict, it is the one about victims reparation. In this case, whether in Palestine or in Lebanon, the citizens of Israel must be aware that the great destructions conducted by their army will have to be refunded by themselves or their children to the Palestinians and the Lebanese, and that it will be a key component of any regional peace process. This notion of reparation and infrastructures destruction should be integrated as of today to the reflexion on the future of the conflict. I will ask Newropeans to add it to the definition of the future European external policy towards the Middle-East.

In this perspective (I’m now addressing the youngest of my Israeli readers), each day that goes increases your debt towards your Lebanese and Palestinian neighbours. Think about it when your leaders promise you that bombs thrown on bridges guarantee your future! Money cannot cover human losses; however, it can cover material destruction and thus contribute to highlight the political and moral cost of a conflict.

For the Europeans of the years to come, who will be careful that their direct neighbourhood is as prosperous and democratic as possible, the time is ripe to define the axes of their policy towards the various players of the Israelo-Arab conflict. In the same way that the EU will no longer tolerate terrorist acts from the Arab side, it will impose similar rules onto Israel.  And it is in a position to enforce such policy considering Israel’s growing dependence on the EU. Indeed it is now easy to see how little reliable the US is becoming a partner for Israel in the long term. Recent debates in the US (those launched by Harvard in particular) on the excessive influence of Israeli interests over the US external policy, hint at an evolution leading to the progressive disengagement of the « American ally ». Energy interests, political, military and economic weakening, yesterday’s « superpower » is becoming « superpowerless ». Nevertheless, decisions made today by Israeli leaders seem to take for granted that there will always be a US superpower to help Israel transgress international laws with impunity, or resist forever a constantly growing arabo-muslim world.

A Jewish proverb says: “If one man calls you a horse, hit him. If two men call you a horse, call them fools. If three men call you a horse, saddle up! ». It is time that Israel buys the saddle of international law, and the Europeans can help. The Europeans of the years to come will not be the allies of Israel in the sense the US became their allies, i.e. as accomplices. But they will be reliable partners, aware of History, and aware of what It has taught us all: the further away you drift from the international laws built up by democracies, the more likely become the worst moral drifts.
 
Franck Biancheri, Newropeans President
Paris (France) 

(English translation of an article published in French in NM on July 21st)

[1] Attributable to the paralysis of German leaders on this issue, in particular. In today’s shaping up political and democratic Europe, the « German historic specificity » when it comes to the state of Israel (which is not the Jewish people) will be diluted in the 500 million European citizens mass. Israeli citizens must be aware that this specificity will not last more than another decade.

{moscomment}
Last Updated ( Thursday, 03 August 2006 )
 
< Prev   Next >

Franck Biancheri, président de Newropeans, père d'Erasmus et directeur LEAP2020

Conférence 'Italie/Europe: La démocratie en danger' avec Beppe Grillo, 6 février 2010 - Paris Marianne Ranke-Cormier, directrice de publication de Newropeans Magazine présente Franck Biancheri, président de Newropeans, un des pères fondateurs du programme Erasmus et directeur de recherche de LEAP2020.

 

 
Deutsche Seite
2010 bis 2020: Gold erringt K.O.-Sieg über den Dollar

Thursday, 04 February 2010 | Leap/E2020

article thumbnailDie US-Zentralbank ist nicht mehr in der Lage, ihren Jahrzehnte langen Kampf gegen Gold unter dem Schlagwort vom „Überbleibsel aus barbarischen Zeiten“ führen, mit dem die alles überragende Stellung des Dollars im internationalen Währungssystem...
Weiter lesen

Irre.. schlicht Irre.. und täglich werden es mehr !

Thursday, 21 January 2010 | H-J. Fandrich

article thumbnail   H-J. Fandrich Durchschnittlich brach in den letzten 2 Jahren täglich ein Institut zusammen.. ► 346 Finanzinstitute 2008/09...
Weiter lesen

Mehr ...
Blog Italiano
[Conferenza] LA DEMOCRAZIA IN PERICOLO - Italia - Europa - I cittadini resistono

Thursday, 04 February 2010 | Newropeans

article thumbnail Il bisogno di democrazia in Europa è sempre più forte. Le forze democratiche tentano di ridurre i nostri diritti impedendoci di poter scegliere liberamente mantenendo così al potere, nei nostri paesi e sul nostro continente, un élite corrotta...
Legga più

Record negativo per la Spagna: superati 4 milioni di disoccupati

Thursday, 04 February 2010 | Francesco Rossolini

article thumbnailLa Spagna ha superato la cifra vertiginosa dei 4 milioni di disoccupati. Il dato è ufficiale ed è particolarmente allarmante.
Legga più

Kapuscinski: ritratto e autoritratto di un esploratore di anime

Thursday, 04 February 2010 | Damiano Mazzotti

article thumbnail “Kapuscinski. Opere” è la meravigliosa biografia del più grande reporter di guerra (1932-2007), con la raccolta degli scritti più preziosi e “magici” di uno dei più grandi interpreti di culture (Mondadori, 2009).
Legga più

Página española
Zapatero, Galeano y Haití

Thursday, 04 February 2010 | Alberto Montero Soler

article thumbnailMientras la comunidad internacional alerta sobre la ocupación militar estadounidense de Haití realizada bajo la excusa de la ayuda humanitaria, al presidente Zapatero no se le ocurre otra cosa que decir en el Parlamento Europeo que “ver...
Lea el artículo

Mas ...
Nederlandse Blog
[Europese gedachten] De schijndemocratie van het burgerintiatief

Thursday, 04 February 2010 | Chris Aalberts

article thumbnailBinnenkort begint eindelijk de Europese directe democratie. In het verdrag van Lissabon is de mogelijkheid van een burgerinitiatief opgenomen: burgers kunnen een voorstel doen aan de Europese Commissie om een wetsvoorstel te maken op een bepaald...
Lees meer

Het kost een paar centen....

Thursday, 04 February 2010 | Veronique Swinkels

article thumbnailVolgens de Brusselse professor Matthijs hebben wij in Nederland het op een na duurste koningshuis van de wereld. Alleen de Britse koningin leeft op grotere voet. ... Of we goedkoper uit zouden zijn met een President is natuurlijk ook maar de vraag....
Lees meer

Blog Newropeans
[Conference] La démocratie en danger - Italie, Europe: Des citoyens résistent

Thursday, 04 February 2010

article thumbnailConférence-débat Samedi 6 février 2010 à 14h30 - Paris avec Beppe Grillo, Franck Biancheri et Marco Travaglio [Conferenza] LA DEMOCRAZIA IN PERICOLO - Italia - Europa - I cittadini resistono - Non mancare a questo evento
+ Full Story

More...
Open Tribune Tribunes Ouvertes
Iraq: Upon whom will the ashes of Baghdad fall down?

The three post-war scenarios regarding EU-US relations
On March 17th 2003, seven years ago, on the eve of the US invasion of Iraq, Franck Biancheri published three scenarios attempting to describe the war's possible consequences. Among the three he qualified one as most likely to happen. Because of its striking anticipation of what is indeed happening today, we have decided to put it online again.
Upon whom will the ashes of Baghdad fall down? The three post-war scenarios regarding EU-US relations

 
Beppe Grillo, Franck Biancheri, Marco Travaglio.... Samedi 6 février à Paris

+ Full Story
Cartoons of the week
global what?

Zoran Zlaticanin

article thumbnail

+ Full Story
for dummies...

MJ

article thumbnail

+ Full Story
The end

Resad Sultanovic

article thumbnail

+ Full Story
euro-way

Mileta Miloradopvic

article thumbnail

+ Full Story
HJF Portofolio
Das Davos - Syndrom - Hackerangriffe und Ruhe ist

Thursday, 04 February 2010

article thumbnail

+ Full Story
Europstat
292 - 5 millions - 2 milliards

Thursday, 21 January 2010

article thumbnail 292 morts, plus de 5 millions de personnes vaccinées au 1er janvier… et une facture de 2 milliards d’euros. Tel est le coût estimé de 3 mois de...
+ Full Story

NM Blogs
About NM
About us
Join Us
Partners
Links
Legal info
NM Newsletter


Receive HTML?



 
PETITION

We all are Icelanders, fed up to pay for the banks failures!
In any case, to prove that all Europeans are not like the British and Dutch governments, Newropeans is launching a petition called « We all are Icelanders, fed up with paying for banks failures» and aiming at gathering popular support for the Icelandic resistance to the current outrageous 'financial order'.
SIGN HERE

Nous sommes tous des Islandais, ras le bol de payer pour les banquiers!
Pour prouver que tous les Européens ne sont pas à l'image des gouvernements britannique et néerlandais, Newropeans lance la pétition "Nous sommes tous des Islandais, ras le bol de payer pour les banquiers! " pour rassembler un soutien populaire à la résistance des Islandais à l'inique "ordre financier" actuel.
SIGNEZ LA PETITION ICI

Clicca qui per firmare la petizione - Klik hier om de petitie te tekenen - Unterzeichnen Sie hier