Balkans: The Last of the Yugoslavs, ...and the Right to Musaka PDF Print E-mail
Written by Risto Karajkov   
Tuesday, 11 March 2008

 

ImageThe disintegration of Yugoslavia, which began back in 1991 has so far produced seven successor states. The last one was Kosovo which declared independence on 17 February.

Back in 2003, when the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia was renamed into a State Union of Serbia and Montenegro - three years later, Montenegro went its separate way, by holding a referendum on independence –the name Yugoslavia was erased from the map. Yugoslavia was effectively - no more.

Close, but not completely accurate. One of the successors of Tito’s socialist federation, still keeps memory to Yugoslavia. It is Macedonia.

In 1993, due to Greek opposition to the use of the word “Macedonia” in the name of the new Balkan republic, the UN accepted the new state into membership under the temporary name “former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (FYROM)”.

Fifteen years later, with the rest of Yugoslavia far forgotten, Macedonia is the last of its off-springs to hold any reference to what once was. It is still a “Yugoslav” republic. It is the last of the Yugoslavs.

But perhaps not for long.

The long -simmering dispute between Greece and Macedonia has recently entered what seems to be a possible final phase.

In the early 1990s, the name dispute delayed Macedonia’s entry into the UN. In 1994 Greece installed a complete embargo against its small northern neighbor, which lasted for 18 months and severely hurt the fragile economy of the fledgling state.

After having reached an agreement, with UN mediation, in late 1995, Greece lifted the embargo and the dispute decreased in intensity over the ensuing years. All until recently, when it exploded again.

Macedonia is expected to get an invitation to join NATO, together with two other countries from the Adriatic group, Albania and Croatia, at a forthcoming summit of the Alliance, in Bucharest in April.

Greece adamantly stated it would veto Macedonia’s entry unless the name dispute resolved first. This angers the United States, which has just led the way for a recognition of Kosovo, and wants the NATO veil of security over the region, in possible turbulences ahead.

It does not make Greece any friends in the EU either. To most countries, which do not understand the obsession with history in the Balkans, the dispute over a name - one of a kind in international relations among states – is irrational. EU Parliament just passed a resolution calling upon Greece not to block Macedonia’s international integration, as long it does it as FYROM.

The US Ambassador to Macedonia recently suggested to both countries to “grow up”.

Yet in both Greece and Macedonia, the name issue these days is (again) perceived as a matter of life or death.

Greece has always claimed that “Macedonia” is an exclusive part of its historic and cultural heritage, and that by using the name, Skopje is stealing its history and perhaps even displaying territorial pretensions.

Macedonia has always claimed that its ethnic Macedonian population has no other identity except the “Macedonian” one, and subsequently no other name.

The last escalation, which actually began by means of political decision, that of the government in Athens to use its position as a NATO member, to put an end to the name dispute, has in recent weeks set off a wave of nationalist hysteria in both Greece and Macedonia.

Recent protest for preservation of the name in the center of Macedonia’s capital Skopje, ended with an unsuccessful attempt by a group of nationalist thugs to attack the Greek Liaison Office. Luckily, the police were in place to prevent it.

Macedonian media reported a spat between Greek and Macedonian soldiers in Afghanistan. Reportedly, a Macedonian cook, prepared a traditional, “local” dish – a musaka (baked dish with meat and various vegetables) and called it “Macedonian musaka”. Greek soldiers refused to eat, saying the musaka was a “traditional Greek dish”, and protested to superiors.

Whereas both countries are ready for some concessions, they do not go far enough and compromise seems elusive, even under strong US pressure to find a solution.

In principle, there is no reason why Macedonia could not enter NATO the same way it entered the UN and other international organizations, as “former” and “Yugoslav” republic, except because Greece won’t allow it. The government in Athens hopes the time is right to apply pressure, from a position of a NATO member, and have the thing resolved favorably once and for all.

Greece says Macedonia threatens regional stability by refusing to compromise (the way Greece would want to). Macedonia says Greece is a security risk because it goes against NATO interests in the region.

Macedonia also insists the issue is essentially a bilateral one of no wider international importance. Greece claims otherwise. It says Macedonia cannot join either NATO or the EU before a solution to the name dispute has been found.

Over the past 16 years, around 120 countries, of which three permanent members of the UN Security Council (Russia, China, and the US) have recognized Macedonia by its real name.

ImageElsewhere may seem strange, but in the Balkans, identity, even if of baked dishes, is taken very seriously.

The same coffee in Bosnia is called “Bosniak” , “Serbian” or whatever coffee. Nobody calls it what it really is- “Turkish” coffee. Turks – who owned everything in the Balkans for a few centuries - do not seem to have a problem with it.

Italians should beware. Who ever gave them the right to call their fruit salad “Macedonia”?

Risto Karajkov*
Skopje & Bologna



Send your comments:  This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it


12/03/2008 - Tony Vuccino

The reason why Greece is objecting to the Macedonian name is very simple and very logical. Let's forget history for a minute and let's use simple Law and International Law.

The Land of the Old Macedonian Empire was partitioned into 3 regions by the Europeans in 1913 ( Vardar or South Serbia (FYROM) ,Pirin Macedonia ( BULGARIA ) and ,Aegean Macedonia ( GREECE )
1- Which one of the 3 Regions have a Legal right to the name?...EITHER ALL OR NONE.
2- If we call all 3 areas Macedonia how can we tell them apart ?....,Unless each one of them has a separate name in front of the word Macedonia. RIGHT?
Or I will give you another example:
A corporation carrying the name of Macedonia with 3 shareholders , when dissolving the Corporation, which one of the 3 shareholders has a right to the name?...EITHER ALL OR NONE.
As food for thought I gave you these examples.
FACTS:
 FYROM's Population according to Wikipedia is as follows:
The "Macedonians (Macedonian": Македонци, Makedonci) – also referred to as Macedonian Slavs – are a South Slavic ethnic group who are primarily associated with the "Republic of Macedonia". They speak the "Macedonian" language, a South Slavic language. About three quarters of all ethnic Macedonians live in the "Republic of Macedonia", POPULATION: 64% Slavs, 25% Albanians 11% others : ( Roma,Turks,Pomacks,Jews,Greeks ).
Taking into consideration all of the above and knowing the History of the Macedon Empire, of Alexander the Great, why the Slavic population of FYROM wants to call themselves Macedonians, is beyond any good Logic,Fairness,or Legality.
Now Europeans,Americans and the rest of the World patiently and politely awaiting a resolution to the problem.
DO NOT HOLD YOUR BREATH....FYR Macedonia is not going to move from their capricious position. Their aspiration is to unite all parts of Old Macedonia ( Greece and Bulgaria ) that's why they circulated a new map showing the other 2 parts in the neighboring Countries as THEIRS. THAT'S WHY THEY WANT TO RETAIN THE NAME MACEDONIA.
MORE...At first they Used the Greek Symbol of the Star of Vergina on their flag ,they changed it to a different star after the International and Greek objection. Then they named Skopje Airport Alexander the Great Airport. 
NOW...do you think that The Macedon Empire was Slavic or Alexander the Great was a Slav ?
We all have internet and very easily we can learn all about the correct history, in any one of the international Encyclopedias.
IN THE NEWS TODAY.
1- FYR Macedonia is fighting now with Kosovo about their Boarders.
2- The FYR Macedonian Government is ready to collapse as the Minority Government is loosing the support from the 11 Albanian Deputies.
3- FYR Macedonia's trade deficit has increased by 45%. 
WHAT'S NEXT?????
For how long would the International community is going to stand by and tolerate this farce and charade ?
Rest my case.
Tony Vuccino
P.S. The best names for this Country is :
Nova Macedonia or Northern Macedonia or Vardar Macedonia or Slavic Macedonia. ...NOW THAT'S A COMPROMISE.
Last Updated ( Wednesday, 12 March 2008 )
< Prev   Next >

Europe and its languages: In varietate concordia

Portrait de la semaine: David Carayol - d'Erasmus à Newropeans
 D'Erasmus à Newropeans - David Carayol a 31 ans. En 1996 il a fait Erasmus, une expérience qui lui a apporté un enrichissement inestimable et surtout une nouvelle dimension: "On arrive français, on repart européen: Pour moi ça résume parfaitement mon expérience Erasmus" une expérience qui le pousse sur les routes de la politique européenne. Ce n'est pas par hasard d'ailleurs qu'il coordonnera cet été la campagne Newropeans sur les plages d'Europe...
Read more...
€-$ Change
Derniers articles
Invited Languages
NM Blog Presse
Cartoons
Agenda politique
• 20.  Mai - Frankfurt am Main 
Wahlkampfauftakt
mit Franck biancheri
u. Margit Reiner-Schober
Saal des Saalbau Gutleut, Rottweiler Straße 32 in 60327 Frankfurt am Main (19.30)
Read more...
The agenda 
of next meetings in the Netherlands
Eindhoven, Den Haag, Tilburg, Nijmegen, Maastricht, Leiden...
Read more...

L'agenda politique des prochaines rencontres en France
Reims, Chateau-Thierry, Nancy, Metz, Strasbourg...

Read more...
Blog Newropeans
Mettons un terme au gâchis de la politique étrangère de l'UE !
Let's put an end to the EU foreign policy mess!

 

Newropeans supports the petition 'No to Tony Blair as President of the European Union'
DECLARATION DE MADRID DE NEWROPEANS
RSS
Qu'est-ce que le RSS ?
What is RSS ?
Newsletter
Keep yourself updated with our FREE newsletters now!

Name:

Email:

Receive HTML mailings?
Subscribe Unsubscribe