Twitter: the most useless political medium in history? Print E-mail
Europolitik
Written by Chris Aalberts   
Thursday, 05 November 2009


You probably know Twitter, the web site where every citizen can tell about his activities. The question ‘what are you doing?’ should be answered in 140 signs. Thousands of citizens already discovered the web site, where they follow their friends, colleages or family members, and where they tell their followers about their activities.

The Dutch minister of Foreign Affairs, Maxime Verhagen, started using Twitter several months ago. At the moment he has more than 20.000 followers who inform themselves about Verhagen’s meetings, travels and opinions. Since then, other politicians discovered Twitter too. They provide citizens with information that was not available in the past: Member of the European Parliament Sophie in ‘t Veld has a debate on friday morning with a well-known lawyer about privacy, a liberal city councillor in The Hague is travelling to a campaign meeting and the political leader of the Green party alerts us that her party member wrote a piece in one of the main newspapers.

You’d better know all these things. It is quite clear that all this information does not serve any purpose: nobody asks for these messages and nobody reads them. Member of Parliament Boris van der Ham twittered once about financial issues. I twittered back that I think that he is unable to make his own calculations. Immediately, a party member replied that I should have included ‘@borisham’ in my tweet, because otherwise Boris would be unable to read it. I twittered that I thought it was uninteresting whether Boris read that tweet, and asked her whether she thought that she had real readers and whether Boris had some. No answer.

Twitter enables these kind of interactions. Politicians who have hundreds of followers can send messages to them for hours if they want to. I asked some local politicians why they actually use this medium. ‘To inform citizens about my work’ was the standard answer. But isn’t this the role of journalists, who also attract a much larger audience than Twitter? It seems some politicians already understand that journalists matter are more important: one of the most popular Dutch politicians, Alexander Pechtold, started on Twitter but stopped after a few tweets. His popularity did not suffer from it.

The chair of the Dutch parliament Gerdi Verbeet wants members of parliament to stop twittering during debates, which makes these members complain in public. I twittered to Member of Parliament Jack Biskop that the quality of many Dutch laws is poor, so that it would be best when Members of Parliament give attention to the debate. No answer. Member of the European Parliament Wim van de Camp wants seperate meetings for Dutch members of the EP. I twittered the question why this is useful, because party differences are more important than national interests. No answer. A politician from Amsterdam talked on Dutch television about gay rights. I twittered him to ask what his financial proposals in this area are. No answer.

This is the lesson of Twitter: it makes politicians look very modern, transparent and interactive. But when problems occur in their work, politicians stop twittering immediately. Information is only provided when it cannot be considered dangerous. Politicians only answer questions that are not critical and when their answers do not reveal any new information. The most useless political medium in history has a name: Twitter.

Chris Aalberts*
Amsterdam, The Netherlands
 

 

* Chris Aalberts is lecturer and researcher in political communication. Visit his blog: http://www.chrisaalberts.nl/ - This paper is also accessible in Dutch

This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
Last Updated ( Thursday, 05 November 2009 )
 
< Prev   Next >

EditoRosenkranz, une impératrice à la Hofburg?

Tuesday, 09 March 2010 | Wiilly Bauer

article thumbnailRosenkranz, littéralement la couronne de roses, pourrait être le prochain titulaire du siège à la Hofburg. - Non Pröll n'ira pas. Eva Glawischnig...
+ Full Story

mod_dbrss2 AJAX RSS Reader poweredbysimplepie
Deutsche Seite
Die 4. Gewalt im Staat

Thursday, 04 March 2010 | H-J. Fandrich

article thumbnail   Hat jemand beherzte Journalisten im Mainstream gesehen ? In den alternativen Medien und Blogs ist der Mut zu Hause. Im Mainstream kann ich ihn kaum finden.  Schade..     Die 4. Gewalt im...
Weiter lesen

Die Türkei erwacht: Absatzbewegung aus dem westlichen Lager

Friday, 26 February 2010 | Franck Biancheri - LEAP/E2020

article thumbnailWährend in der gegenwärtigen umfassenden Krise die Macht der USA und die militärische Stärke des Westens, auf der diese Macht beruhte, rapide zerfällt, beginnt die Türkei ihre außenpolitische Interessenlage zu überdenken und neu zu definieren. Die...
Weiter lesen

Blog Italiano
Decreto "interpretativo" e stato d’eccezione: adesso basta!

Monday, 08 March 2010 | Maurizio Carena

article thumbnail"Caos liste" il Consiglio dei Ministri vara il decreto "interpretativo". Il Quirinale disponibile a esaminarlo. Per Bersani è "un trucco". Per Di Pietro " è "un golpe". I cittadini devono dire BASTA. Anche Mussolini e Hitler erano a capo di...
Legga più

Università: Quella che si gioca, una grande partita

Thursday, 04 March 2010 | Loreza Masè

article thumbnail“L’Università è nostra- ha detto Elena Guercia, Rappresentante degli Studenti - ci sono tante cose sbagliate, dei cambiamenti vanno fatti e noi studenti dovremmo partecipare di più”. Quella che si gioca è una grande partita: si sente la necessità...
Legga più

I giovani hanno bisogno di modelli positivi.

Thursday, 04 March 2010 | Francesco Rossolini

article thumbnailFiniamola di esaltare disadattati semianalfabeti - I modelli positivi dovrebbero essere rappresentai da letterati, matematici, fisici, medici, giuristi, pensatori e certamente anche dagli esponenti più rappresentativi delle avanguardie artistiche.
Legga più

Nederlandse Blog
We zijn allemaal IJslanders, beu om te betalen voor de blunders van banken!

Thursday, 04 March 2010 | Newropeans

article thumbnailWij als Newropeans zouden graag een paar reacties willen geven op het gevecht dat jullie momenteel voeren tegen de ongepaste chantage van de Britse en Nederlandse overheden, aangaande de schulden van de failliete IJslandse...
Lees meer

[Europese gedachten] Oh jee, daar gaat de reputatie van Nederland!

Thursday, 04 March 2010 | Chris Aalberts

article thumbnailAfgelopen week viel de regering over de Nederlandse aanwezigheid in de Afghaanse provincie Uruzgan. Buitenland- en defensie-experts zagen het met veel verbazing en irritatie aan. Zij benadrukten het grote belang van de Nederlandse aanwezigheid in...
Lees meer

Página española
PIGS versus USA

Thursday, 04 March 2010 | Luis Casado

article thumbnailLos países en cuestión son los llamados PIGS, “cerdos” en su acrónimo inglés: Portugal, Ireland, Greece, Spain. Acojonados, los “cerdos” anuncian medidas para reducir sus déficits, disminuir el gasto público, retrasar la edad de la jubilación,...
Lea el artículo

Mas ...
Blog Newropeans
Franck Biancheri & Beppe Grillo: joining the progressive forces in Europe for more democracy

Thursday, 11 February 2010

article thumbnail
+ Full Story

More...
Open Tribune Tribunes Ouvertes
Le bon sens européen absent de la campagne électorale en France
Image Si les candidats à l’élection étaient le syndic de votre co-propriété, les croiriez-vous? Imaginez l’Europe comme un immense bâtiment en co-propriété dont les habitants de votre pays habiteraient une aile et auraient la gestion du fonctionnement de cette partie du bâtiment. Le gouvernement, c’est le syndic ; il gère les affaires courantes de la partie de l’immeuble que vous partagez avec d’autres locataires ou propriétaires: nettoyage, sécurité, entretien des couloirs et des ascenseurs, rémunération du personnel, et bien sûr fixation des charges. Imaginez que chaque pays de l’Union européenne occupe et gère de façon semblable une partie de ce grand bâtiment... Un éditorial de Philippe Portalier écrit à l'occasion des élections présidentielles en France en 2007, d'actualité pour les prochaines régionales: Le bon sens européen absent de la campagne électorale en France
 
Join us

Le débat politique vous dérange,
vos convictions européennes
vous démangent

Pays-Bas: Geert Wilders, la voie extrême pour une sortie de crise?

+ Full Story
- TransEuropeReview - ... Revue de presse ...
Sharp eye - Regards européensSilvio Berlusconi force la loi électorale

article imageNouveau coup de force de Silvio Berlusconi: le décret «interprétatif» de la loi éléctorale italienne, ou comment selon le Figaro le Cavaliere «sauve» douze millions d'électeurs du risque de privation de voter pour un candidat du parti de Berlusconi aux prochaines élections régionales:   Le Figaro: Silvio Berlusconi force la loi électorale
+ Full Story

la quotidienne
europeLe chômage masculin des 15-24 ans atteint un record depuis 1975

Le Journal du Net

Fin 2009, un quart des jeunes ayant terminé ou quitté les études était au chômage (25,3%, contre...
+ Full Story

Spécial Régionales[Elections] Sarkozy en chef de campagne

Le Télégramme

Les derniers sondages, qui mettent le PS et l'UMP à égalité au premier tour, montrent que les...
+ Full Story

Spécial Régionales[Elections] Nicolas Sarkozy and Carla Bruni 'both having affairs'

The Telegraph

The first 'tweet' claimed that Mrs Bruni-Sarkozy had become romantically involved with Benjamin...
+ Full Story

voisinage[Maroc] Affaire Haidar Histoire d’un ratage

Le Journal:

Aux Affaires étrangères marocaines, on peste aujourd’hui contre ces lobbyistes américains qui se...
+ Full Story

europeIceland votes 'No' on repayment plan

NRC Handelsblad:

What comes next? What needs to be done next is the question on everybody’s minds. The outcome...
+ Full Story

europeDutch general says Netherlands replaceable in Afghanistan

NRC Handelsblad:

Army major Marc Zerstegen returned from Uruzgan a few weeks ago. As he flew home, he was not...
+ Full Story

voisinage[Algérie] Rumeurs, scandales, communication biaisée : Une vie politique en trompe-l’œil

El Watan

De plus en plus récurrentes, les dérobades des responsables de l’Etat ont eu pour effet de nourrir...
+ Full Story

europeWas in der EU faul ist / Ce qui est pourri dans l'UE

FT

L'UE s'attaque à la Grèce parce qu'elle ne peut pas mettre en œuvre le pacte de stabilité. Le...
+ Full Story

europePfund verliert weltweit an Wert / Chute mondiale de la livre sterling

FT

Après la Grèce la Grande Bretagne en point de mire. La livre sterling perd face à la majorité...
+ Full Story

europe50 propositions contre le racisme et le communautarisme

Nouvel Obs

Dans un rapport remis au ministère de l'Intérieur, le Conseil représentatif des Associations...
+ Full Story

Cartoons of the week
Hollywood

MJ

article thumbnail

+ Full Story
HJF Portofolio
Die 4. Gewalt im Staat

Thursday, 04 March 2010

article thumbnail

+ Full Story
Europstat
768,8 billion

Sunday, 21 February 2010

article thumbnail Japan 768,8 billion dollars China 755,4 billion dollars United Kingdom 302,5 billion dollars Brazil 160 billion...
+ Full Story

NM Blogs
About NM
About us
Join Us
Partners
Links
Legal info
NM Newsletter


Receive HTML?



Videos of the week
Zic Clip Europe[Belgique] STROMAE - Alors on danse

STROMAE

+ Full Story